What is /p/?
/p/ — the voiceless bilabial plosive — is one of the most widespread phonemes in human language. And yet it is absent from roughly 10%
of the world's languages, and in many others it has weakened, shifted, or vanished under specific
phonological conditions.
This site records those losses. The diagram below is a phonological flow chart — each ribbon
is one lineage of /p/ over time. A ribbon's color is the phoneme as it's articulated at that
year (amber for /p/, blue for /f/, violet for /ɸ/, green for /h/, teal for /ç/, rose for /w/,
grey for ∅). When a single /p/ splits into multiple environments, ribbons fork. When the
color shifts mid-flow, that's a sound change in progress. Pre-evidence sections fade in
from transparent — we know /p/ was there, but its exact form is extrapolated. Dots are
attestation points. The ribbons are grouped by language family so you can see, e.g., the
fates of Indo-European *p side by side.
Drag horizontally to pan; use the zoom controls to expand a period. Hover any ribbon or dot for
details.
The Graveyard
Celtic
Status: Lost in Proto-Celtic
One of the showpiece sound losses of Indo-European studies. PIE *p disappeared early in the
Celtic branch, before Proto-Celtic split into its daughters. The classic cognates expose it:
PIE: *pPCelt: ∅ e.g. *ph₂tḗr → OIr. athair - Latin piscis ~ Old Irish íasc "fish"
/p/ later re-entered Celtic from kw in the P-Celtic branch (Welsh pedwar "four"
< PIE *kʷetwores), but inherited PIE *p never came back.
Arabic
Status: Lost
Proto-Semitic had *p, retained in many sister languages — Hebrew shows it as [p]~[f]
allophony, Akkadian had /p/. Arabic merged it with /f/ before the historical record:
PSem: *pArabic: f - Modern loans: park → bark (بارك) or fark (فارك)
Chinese
Status: Partially alive
Old Chinese had *p. In late Middle Chinese the labial initials split — 輕唇音 (light
labials) and 重唇音 (heavy labials) — and *p underwent labiodentalization before specific
medial-vowel combinations:
MC: pMand.: p elsewhere e.g. 北 běi MC: pMand.: f _jɨ, _ju, _jo e.g. 飛 fēi,
風 fēng
Modern Mandarin keeps /p/ in plenty of words, but a large slice of the inherited vocabulary
exited via /f/.
Japanese
Status: Conditioned loss — /p/ survived in narrow environments
and was later reinforced by loans.
The most thoroughly documented case. Old Japanese /p/ weakened to /ɸ/ in most positions
by the late Heian period, then split further by the following vowel. It was never
eliminated outright — the {Q, N}_V branch carried /p/ through unchanged — and from
the 16th century onward loanwords added /p/ back in unrestricted positions.
OJ: pMJ: ɸ V_V MJ: ɸmJ: h _{a, o, e} MJ: ɸmJ: ç _i MJ: ɸmJ: ɸ _u (marginal)
OJ: pmJ: p {Q, N}_V e.g. 切符 kippu, 散歩 sanpo
/p/ then re-entered unrestricted positions wholesale: first via Portuguese loans (1543: pan, tabako), then Dutch, and at scale through modern English loans —
reinforcing a phoneme that had narrowly survived the Heian-era weakening.
References
- Frellesvig, Bjarke (2010). A History of the Japanese Language.
Cambridge University Press. — The standard handbook on the OJ /p/ chain, including the
intervocalic /ɸ/ → /β/ → /w/ → ∅ pathway and the post-Heian split by following vowel.
- Miyake, Marc Hideo (2003). Old Japanese: A Phonetic Reconstruction.
RoutledgeCurzon. — Reconstruction arguments for OJ [p] versus other proposals.
- Baxter, William H. & Laurent Sagart (2014). Old Chinese: A New
Reconstruction. Oxford University Press. — Reconstruction of OC *p- and its Middle
Chinese reflexes.
- Pulleyblank, Edwin G. (1984). Middle Chinese: A Study in Historical
Phonology. UBC Press. — Late Middle Chinese labiodentalization (輕唇音 vs 重唇音
split).
- Matasović, Ranko (2009). Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic.
Brill. — Proto-Celtic *p > ∅, with discussion of the *p → *ɸ → *h → ∅ intermediate
stages.
- Schrijver, Peter (1995). Studies in British Celtic Historical
Phonology. Rodopi. — On the loss of PIE *p in Celtic and the secondary /p/ in Brythonic
from *kʷ.
- Ringe, Don (2017). From Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic (2nd
ed.). Oxford University Press. — Grimm's Law and the PIE *p > PGmc *f shift.
- Lipiński, Edward (2001). Semitic Languages: Outline of a Comparative
Grammar (2nd ed.). Peeters. — Proto-Semitic *p in Arabic, Hebrew, Akkadian.
- Huehnergard, John (2011). A Grammar of Akkadian (3rd ed.).
Eisenbrauns. — Akkadian /p/ inventory and Semitic comparative context.
- Suchard, Benjamin D. (2024). "Froto-Semitic".
— Notes on the PSem *p > Arabic /f/ correspondence and adaptation of foreign /p/.
- Krishnamurti, Bhadriraju (2003). The Dravidian Languages.
Cambridge University Press. — South Dravidian *p- > h- in Middle Kannada (e.g. *pāl
> hāl(u) "milk"); retention in Tamil.
- Steever, Sanford B. (ed., 1998). The Dravidian Languages.
Routledge. — Per-language descriptions including Kannada initial debuccalization.
- Wikipedia — Old Japanese, Grimm's Law, Proto-Celtic, Proto-Semitic.
— First-stop summaries for each lineage.